Croxley’s Great American Ale House & Beer Garden

Recommendations Learn more

• Threes SFY (Formerly Superf*ckingyawn)

  Double IPA · 8.3% · Brooklyn, NY

  Tropical, Assertive, Lush, Oily, Candied Tangerines. Hopped with Mosaic, Simcoe & Columbus. Imperial Pale Ale.

  25cl Draft $9

  Local|Highly rated|Popular

• Destination Unknown Science of Selling Pina Coladas

  NE/Hazy IPA · 7.0% · Bay Shore, NY

  SoSo with lactose, pinapple, coconut and vanilla.

  25cl Draft $9

  Local|Great brewery

Rotating Rarities

• Destination Unknown Abuse Of Powder Cashmere

  NE/Hazy DIPA · 8.8% · Bay Shore, NY

  25cl Draft $8

• Destination Unknown Abuse Of Stout

  Imperial Stout · 12.0% · Bay Shore, NY

  Imperial stout with honey cocoa nibs and vanilla

  25cl Draft $9

• Equilibrium + Unseen Creatures To Space We Go

  NE/Hazy DIPA · 8.0% · Middletown, NY

  To Space We Go starts off with 2row, flaked oats and flaked wheat before a Mosaic whirlpool and a dry hop of Strata... more

  25cl Draft $9

• Finback Rolling in Clouds

  IPA · 7.1% · Queens, NY

  Flagship hazy IPA

  25cl Draft $8

• Grimm Magnetic Tape

  IPA · 6.4% · Brooklyn, NY

  Juicy IPA brewed with Mosaic and Motueka hops.

  25cl Draft $9

• Platform Haze Jude

  IPA · 6.7% · Cleveland, OH

  Brewed exclusively with Simcoe and a new, yet-to-be-named experimental hop. This haze-filled wonder is a pineapple bomb that drinks smooth and is nougat-like chewy.

  16oz Draft $8

• Threes SFY (Formerly Superf*ckingyawn)

  Double IPA · 8.3% · Brooklyn, NY

  Tropical, Assertive, Lush, Oily, Candied Tangerines. Hopped with Mosaic, Simcoe & Columbus. Imperial Pale Ale.

  25cl Draft $9

• Toppling Goliath King Sue

  Double IPA · 7.8% · Decorah, IA

  This lusciously hazy double IPA gains its hints of mango, orange, and pineapple from the use of the delicious Citra hop.

  25cl Draft $10

New & Seasonal

• 21st Amendment Hell or High Watermelon

  Wheat Ale · 4.9% · San Francisco, CA

  Using fresh watermelon that delivers a very unique refreshing fruity taste.

  16oz Draft $7

• Destination Unknown Science of Selling Pina Coladas

  NE/Hazy IPA · 7.0% · Bay Shore, NY

  SoSo with lactose, pinapple, coconut and vanilla.

  25cl Draft $9

• Sam Seasonal Summer Ale

  Wheat Ale · 5.3% · Boston, MA

  Lemon peel adds a bright citrus note that’s complemented by spicy, citrusy Hallertau Mittelfrueh and Saaz Noble hops.

  16oz Draft $7

• Schofferhofer Grapefruit Hefeweizen

  German Hefeweizen · 2.5% · Frankfurt, Hesse

  Schofferhofer grapefruit is a unique combination of sparkling wheat beer and refreshing tangy fruit juice.

  16oz Draft $7

Drink Long Island

• Blue Point Blueberry Ale

  Fruit Beer · 4.6% · Patchogue, NY

  A wonderful blend of fresh blueberries matched with a thirst quenching distinctive ale.

  16oz Draft $7

• Blue Point Toasted Lager

  Vienna Lager · 5.5% · Patchogue, NY

  6 different malts..English Pale, Crystal, Munich, Carapils, Wheat and Belgian Caravienna.

  16oz Draft $7

• Brooklyn Lager

  Lager · 5.2% · New York, NY

  Caramel-forward amber lager with a refreshing dry-hopped aroma.

  16oz Draft $7

• Greenport Harbor Tiki Paradise

  Sour Ale · 5.8% · Greenport, NY

  25cl Draft $8

• Montauk Wave Chaser

  IPA · 6.4% · Montauk, NY

  A bitter, moderately strong American pale ale that uses its clean, supporting malt to showcase its hop character.

  16oz Draft $7

Essential Craft

• Kona Big Wave Golden Ale

  Golden Ale · 4.4% · Kailua Kona, HI

  It shines with its tropical hop aroma & flavor with a balance of sweet lightly roasted honey malt.

  16oz Draft $7

• Lagunitas A Little Sumpin'

  16oz Draft $7

IPA, Pale & Amber

• Dogfish Head 60 Minute

  IPA · 6.0% · Milton, Delaware

  Brewed with a slew of great Northwest hops. A powerful but balanced East Coast IPA with a lot of citrusy hop character.

  16oz Draft $7

• Goose Island Goose IPA

  IPA · 5.9% · Chicago, IL

  Our IPA recalls a time when ales shipped from England to India were highly hopped to preserve their distinct taste during the long journey.

  16oz Draft $7

• Palm Belgian Amber Ale

  Amber Ale · 5.4% · Steenhuffel, Belgium

  Made with English hops, French Barley, and Belgian yeast, PALM represents the best of European beer-making traditions.

  33cl Draft $7

• Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

  American Pale Ale · 5.6% · CA & NC

  Unique piney and grapefruit aromas from the use of whole-cone American hops have fascinated beer drinkers for decades and made this beer a classic.

  16oz Draft $7

• Stone IPA

  IPA · 6.9% · Escondido, CA

  Exploding with citrusy, piney hop flavors and aromas, all perfectly balanced by a subtle malt character. A crisp, extra hoppy brew.

  16oz Draft $8

Pilsner, Light & Amber Lager

• Bavik Super Pils

  Pilsner · 5.2% · Bavikhove, Belgium

  Bavik. A true Belgian Pilsner, crafted by Brewery De Brabandere in Bavikhove, Belgium. This pilsner is uncompromised, brewed as it was in 1894. What makes Bavik a Super Pils?....... 100% MALT - No dilution assures the quality of the Pilsner. All ingredients are added during the brew process... more

  33cl Draft $7

• Croxley Blonde

  Blonde Ale · 6.0% · New York, NY

  Croxley Blonde is a bright golden ale with a sweet lemony start, pedaling to a pleasantly bitter finish.

  16oz Draft $6

• Hofbräu Original

  Helles Lager · 5.1% · München, Germany

  A golden, clear beer, richly aromatic, and pleasantly mild. A perfect example of the "Müenchener Helles" style.

  16oz Draft $7

• Modelo Especial

  Pale Lager · 4.4% · Anáhuac, México

  Well-balanced taste and light hop character with a crisp, clean finish. Characterized by an orange blossom honey aroma with a hint of herb.

  16oz Draft $7

• Radeberger Pilsner Zwickelbier

  Kellerbier · 4.8% · frankfurt am main, hessen germany

  Unfiltered. Served exclusively at selected accounts in the U.S.

  16oz Draft $7

• Samuel Adams Boston Lager

  Lager · 5.0% · Boston, MA

  The beer that started it all for Samuel Adams. This unmistakable, full-flavored beer sparked a movement to bring better beer to U.S. drinkers. Boston Lager illustrates our core mission to brew flavorful, complex and delicious beers... more

  16oz Draft $7

• Stella Artois Pale Lager

  Pale Lager · 5.2% · Leuven, Belgium

  Premium European lager of noble traditions that is still brewed using natural ingredients in the same processes of mixing and fermentation used in the old days.

  33cl Draft $7

• Yuengling Traditional Lager

  Pale Lager · 4.5% · Pottsville, PA

  Famous for its rich amber color and medium-bodied flavor with roasted caramel malt for a subtle sweetness and a combination of cluster and cascade hops.

  16oz Draft $7

Wheat Beer

• Hoegaarden White

  Witbier · 4.9% · St. Louis, MO

  Soft taste, light and slightly sweet and sour and with subtle citrus notes.

  33cl Draft $7

• Paulaner Hefe-Weizen

  German Hefeweizen · 5.5% · München

  Germany. Naturally cloudy and shining silky gold in the glass under a really strong head of foam. This Weißbier classic has a mild aroma of banana.

  20oz Draft $8

• Shock Top Belgian White

  Wheat Ale · 5.2% · St. Louis, MO

  With real orange, lemon and lime peels and then added a little coriander spice to the mix.

  20oz Draft $8

Strong Golden Ale

• Allagash Tripel

  Tripel · 9.0% · Portland, ME

  Belgian-style golden ale. Aromas of passion fruit and herbs accompany a dry finish.

  25cl Draft $10

• Delirium Tremens

  Belgian Strong Ale · 8.5% · Melle, Belgium

  The allusion to pink elephants and the choice of names is not due to chance. With a particular character, the unique taste of results from the use of three different kinds of yeast. The result is a finish of peppery bitterness without aggression.

  25cl Draft $10

• Waterzooi Grand Cru

  Tripel · 9.0% · Ertvelde, Belgium

  Waterzooi Grand Cru is an elegant blond Belgian Tripel with champagne-like carbonation.

  25cl Draft $9

Dark Ale & Lager

• Gulden Draak Brewmaster Reserve

  Belgian Strong Ale · 10.5% · Ertvelde, Belgium

  This Exclusive Gulden Draak combines the technology and the craftsmanship of the traditional brewing process.

  25cl Draft $9

• St. James’s Gate Guinness

  Dry Stout · 4.2% · Dublin, Ireland

  Rich and creamy. Distinctively black. Velvety in its finish. This iconic beer is defined by harmony.

  20oz Draft $7

• St. James’s Gate Smithwick's Red Ale

  Irish Red Ale · 4.5% · Dublin, Ireland

  A ruby red brew with a gentle hop bitterness and a sweet malt finish.

  16oz Draft $7

Fruit Beer & Cider

• Abita Purple Haze

  Fruit Beer · 4.2% · Covington, LA

  Purple Haze is brewed with pilsner and wheat malts and Vanguard hops. The berries add a fruity aroma, tartly sweet taste and a subtle purple color and haze...you may see fruit pulp in the beer.

  16oz Draft $7

• Angry Orchard Crisp

  Cider · 5.0% · Cincinnati, OH

  Angry Orchard Crisp Apple is the #1 hard cider in the country. It is refreshing, delicious, and tastes like biting into a fresh apple. Crisp Apple has just the right amount of sweetness that makes is the perfect drink when you’re looking for something a little different... more

  16oz Draft $7

• Magic Hat #9

  American Pale Ale · 5.1% · South Burlington, VT

  A sort of dry, crisp, refreshing, not-quite pale ale.

  16oz Draft $7

• Sam Adams Samuel Adams Cherry Wheat

  Wheat Ale · 5.3% · Boston, MA

  Michigan cherries are the key to this flavorful American wheat ale. The cherries contribute a tart fruit character, while a touch of honey adds a slight sweetness. The malt’s crisp cereal notes and subtle citrus of Noble hops create depth and lead to a refreshing finish... more

  16oz Draft $7

Cider Bottles & Cans

• Ace Apple Cider

  Cider · 5.0% · Sebastopol, CA

  A fresh, clean cider made out of a mixture of 6 different pressed dessert apple varieties, with a slight spritz.

  12oz Bottle $7

• Ace Berry Rosé

  Cider · 5.0% · Sebastopol, CA

  Strawberry, blackberry, raspberry, & apple juices blended w/ our fermented Cider base.

  12oz Bottle $7

• Ace Perry

  Cider · 5.0% · Sebastopol, CA

  Semi-sweet pear cider with Madagascar vanilla.

  12oz Bottle $7

• Ace Pineapple Cider

  Cider · 5.0% · Sebastopol, CA

  It is extremely refreshing and very quaffable for cider, beer, or wine drinkers.

  12oz Bottle $7

• Rekorderlig Mango Raspberry Cider

  Cider · 4.5% · Sweden

  Rekorderlig Mango-Raspberry Hard Cider is packed with the juiciest raspberries and a burst of mango to deliver the freshest tropical flavors.

  12oz Can $8

• Rekorderlig Strawberry Lime

  Cider · 4.5% · Vimmerby, Sweden

  Rekorderlig Strawberry-Lime Cider perfectly embodies a Swedish summer with the authentic flavor of freshly picked strawberries.

  12oz Can $8

• Rekorderlig Wild Berries

  Cider · 4.5% · Vimmerby, Sweden

  Mixed berry flavoured cider from Sweden.

  11.2oz Can $8

• Truly Lemon Iced Tea

  Tea Beer · 5.0% · Boston, MA

  Truly Lemon Tea combines hard seltzer with real brewed tea and lemon flavor for a uniquely delicious, refreshing drink. Each 12oz. can has 5% alc./vol., 100 calories, 1g sugars, 2g carbs, and is Gluten Free.

  12oz Can $7

• Truly Strawberry Lemonade

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · Boston, MA

  Hard seltzer with natural flavor. Hard seltzer with natural flavors. 210 calories. 1 g sugars. 5 g carbs. Gluten free. Please drink responsibly.

  12oz Can $7

• White Claw Black Cherry

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · Chicago, IL

  Sparkling rush of 100% pure seltzer water, our BrewPure alcohol & a hint of juicy black cherry is the perfect combination of pure refreshment & subtle ripe flavor

  12oz Can $7

• White Claw Natural Lime

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · Seattle, WA

  A clean fresh aroma leads to dry and incredibly refreshing taste with just a hint of natural juicy lime notes coming through. A crisp, clean spiked sparkling water, with minimal sweetness and no aftertaste – just a lingering hint of tangy lime.

  12oz Can $7

• White Claw Raspberry

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · Seattle, WA

  White Claw Raspberry is the perfect blend of seltzer water, the cleanest tasting alcohol base, and a hint of raspberry.

  12oz Can $7

• Woodchuck Pearsecco

  Dry Cider · 6.1% · Middlebury, VT

  Inspired by sparkling wines, this dry pear cider is full of bubbles with a clean, crisp finish.

  12oz Bottle $6

Specialty Cans & Bottles

• Alchemist Focal Banger

  IPA · 7.0% · Waterbury, VT

  Crisp, clean malt character supporting copious additions of Citra and Mosaic hops.

  16oz Can $13

• Alchemist Heady Topper

  Double IPA · 8.0% · Waterbury, VT

  An American Double IPA. Drink from the can.

  16oz Can $13

• Barrage Fluxinator

  Sweet Stout · 7.7% · East Farmingdale, NY

  Coffee stout with maple syrup and lactose.

  16oz Can $8

• Boddingtons Pub Ale

  Cream Ale · 4.7% · Samlesbury, Lancashire

  Creamy head and a golden well balanced body.

  16oz Can $6

• Clown Shoes Space Cake

  Double IPA · 9.0% · Ipswich, MA

  Double IPA utilizing citrusy mosaic hops and an immaculate west coast style malt backbone.

  16oz Can $8

• DuClaw Dirty Little Freak

  Brown Ale · 5.8% · Hanover, MD

  ‘Dirty Little Freak’ is our 5.8% coconut-caramel-chocolate brown ale that’s drinkably decadent, and slightly malty and with a gentle hop bite.

  12oz Bottle $6

• DuClaw Sweet Baby Jesus!

  Porter · 6.2% · Hanover, MD

  This Chocolate Peanut Butter Porter is jet black in color with a tan, rocky head, full body and creamy, luxurious mouthfeel. Its lightly sweet, malty flavor is accented by strong notes of chocolate, coffee and peanut butter, and balanced by a subtle hop

  12oz Bottle $6

• Eagle Banana Bread Beer

  Lager · 5.2% · Bedford, Bedfordshire England

  Fresh bananas pack a whole bunch of aromas, which rich, malty hops deliver a seriously fruity flavor. All perfectly balanced by a masterful blend.

  12oz Bottle $7.50

• Garvies Point Tusk 'Till Dawn

  Milk Stout · 8.0% · Glen Cove, NY

  Tusk Till Dawn is our first collaboration beer with our friends Barage brewing! It's part of our "Welwyn Walls" Series. This Imperial Milk Stout is brewed with lactose, peanut butter powder, and cacao nibs... more

  16oz Can $8

• Green's Discovery Amber

  Dubbel · 6.0% · Lochristi, Vlaanderen Belgium

  Gluten-Free Medium-bodied with subtle caramel and nut flavor nuances. Refined, herbal hop aroma and finish.

  16.9oz Bottle $15

• Heineken 0.0

  Non-Alcoholic · 0.0% · Netherlands

  Heineken 0.0 is brewed and fermented with Heineken’s unique A-yeast made with natural ingredients, gentle alcohol removal and blending to achieve a fruity flavor and slight malty notes

  12oz Bottle $5

• Omission Gluten Free IPA

  Gluten Free Beer · 6.7% · Portland, OR

  The heavy-handed use of Cascade and Summit hops give it notable pine, citrus, and grapefruit aromas and flavors.

  12oz Bottle $6

• St. Pauli Girl Non-Alcoholic

  Non-Alcoholic · 0.5% · Bremen, Germany

  This N.A. has been a Gold Medal winner for the American Tasting Institute Best Imported Non-Alcoholic Malt Beverage.

  12oz Bottle $5

• Stone Arrogant Bastard

  American Strong Ale · 7.2% · Escondido, CA

  You probably won’t like it. It is quite doubtful that you have the taste or sophistication to appreciate an ale of this quality and depth.

  16oz Can $11

• Stone Buenaveza Salt & Lime Lager

  Mexican Lager · 4.7% · Escondido, CA

  With mucho gusto, we now present our take on a classic lager with Salt & Lime added.

  12oz Can $7

Bottles

• Chimay Cinq Cents (White)

  Tripel · 8.0% · Baileux, Belgium

  Fruity touches of Muscat grapes and raisins, even ripe apples. Of a golden colour, the Trappist beer combines sweet and bitter in a rare balance.

  12oz Bottle $13

• Chimay Grand Reserve

  Belgian Strong Ale · 9.0% · Baileux, Belgium

  Its flavour noticed when tasting it, only accentuates the pleasant sensations perceived in the aroma, while revealing a light but pleasant touch of roasted malt

  12oz Bottle $12

• Chimay Premiere (Red)

  Dubbel · 7.0% · Baileux, Belgium

  First beer brewed by the monks of Chimay in 1862. Topped with a creamy head, it gives off a light, fruity apricot aroma produced by the fermentation. The taste perceived in the mouth is a balance confirming the fruity nuances noticed in the fragrance.

  12oz Bottle $13

• Duvel

  Belgian Strong Ale · 8.5% · Breendonk-Puurs

  Duvel is a natural beer with a subtle bitterness, a refined flavour and a distinctive hop character.

  11.2oz Bottle $12

• Franziskaner Hefe-Weissbier Naturtrüb

  German Hefeweizen · 5.0% · München

  Franziskaner Hefe-Wessbier Naturtrüb is a natural and elegant Weissbier from Bavaria with a lush white foam.

  16.9oz Bottle $8

• Fuller's ESB

  ESB · 5.9% · Chiswick Ln S, London

  Rich mahogany in colour, ESB tempts with aromas of orange marmalade, balanced by soft malt toffee

  11.2oz Bottle $7

• Monk's Cafe Flemish Sour Ale

  Sour Ale · 5.5% · Ertvelde, Belgium

  We blend young and old beers to make this mildy tart sour ale. Light bodied with a lactic/sour nose and a bit of sweet and sour in the finish. Very refreshing!

  12oz Bottle $9.50

• New Belgium Fat Tire

  Amber Ale · 5.2% · CO & NC

  Fat Tire Amber is the easy-drinking Amber Ale born in Colorado from New Belgium Brewing Company, a certified B-Corp. Visual: Clear, amber and bright with white lacing. Aroma: Sweet biscuity and caramel malts, subtle notes of fresh fennel and green apple... more

  12oz Bottle $7

• Ommegang Hennepin

  Saison · 7.7% · Cooperstown, NY

  A Belgian-style farmhouse ale, it's brewed w/ coriander, sweet orange peel and ginger. Hearty, rustic golden ale, full bodied, hoppy and crisp.

  12oz Bottle $8

• Samuel Smith's Organic Chocolate Stout

  Stout · 5.0% · Tadcaster, N. Yorkshire

  Brewed with well water (the original well, sunk in 1758, is still in use with the hard well water being drawn from 85 feet underground).

  12oz Bottle $8

• Samuel Smith's Organic Nut Brown Ale

  Brown Ale · 5.0%

  Nut Brown Ale is relatively dry with a rich amber-brown colour and nutty flavour derived exclusively from small amounts of dark malt.

  12oz Bottle $8

• Schneider Aventinus

  Weizen Bock · 8.2% · Kelheim, Germany

  Dark ruby, glistening mysteriously, streaked with fine, top-fermented yeast, this beer has a compact, stable and long-lasting head.

  16.9oz Bottle $10

• Weihenstephaner Hefeweissbier

  German Hefeweizen · 5.4% · Freising, Germany

  Our amber wheat beer, with its fine-poured white foam, smells of cloves and impresses consumers with its refreshing banana flavor. It is full-bodied with a smooth yeast taste.

  16oz Bottle $8

• Weihenstephaner Vitus

  Weizen Bock · 7.7% · Freising, Germany

  Our light-coloured, spicy single-bock Vitus is offers a fruity smell of dried apricots joined by aromas of citrus, cloves and hints of banana.

  16.9oz Bottle $8

Update this Beer Menu