Bay Shore Beer

Recommendations Learn more

• Sand City Even Mo' Mofo

  Double IPA · 8.5% · Northport, NY

  We created an amplified version of our Mofosaic IPA brewed with English and American pale malts and flaked oats. Hopped intensely and singularly with Mosaic hops.

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $18.99

  Rare|Local|Highly rated

• Fat Orange Cat Jalapeno Jack

  Cream Ale · 3.4% · East Hampton, CT

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $10.86

  Rare|Great brewery

Cans

• 1911 Beak & Skiff Black Cherry

  Cider · 6.9% · LaFayette, NY

  Light up the night with the electrifyingly crisp and slightly tart flavor of 1911 Black Cherry Hard Cider

  16oz Can $3.69

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $13.69

• 1911 Beak & Skiff Raspberry

  Cider · 5.5% · LaFayette, NY

  Starting with our Original hard cider an infusion of raspberries creates a hint of raspberry flavor with a crisp clean finish.

  16oz Can $3.69

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $13.69

• 1911 Beak & Skiff Shandy Hard Cider

  Cider · 6.5% · LaFayette, NY

  Why should the beer drinkers have all the fun? Cider fans are just as deserving of some lemonade love! Grab a bikini, a towel, some screen, and a can, and you’ve got the perfect recipe for some fun in the sand!

  16oz Can $3.69

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $13.69

• 1911 Original Hard Cider

  Cider · 5.5% · LaFayette, NY

  A unique fermentation process creates a clean cider that has a subtle hint of fresh apples with citrus overtones.

  16oz Can $3.69

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $13.69

• 1940's Just Tap It In

  NE/Hazy IPA · 7.5% · Long Island, NY

  With notes of orange lemon lime and tropical fruit

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $16.99

• 1940's Sinners Mass

  Milk Stout · 7.2% · Long Island, NY

  Milk stout with a taste of vanilla.

  16oz Can $3.90

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $14.55

• 1940's Wicked Chowdah IPA

  IPA · 7.2% · Long Island, NY

  A bitter, moderately strong American pale ale that uses its clean, supporting malt to showcase its hop character.

  16oz Can $4.29

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $15.99

• 21st Amendment Brew Free Or Die Hazy IPA

  NE/Hazy IPA · 6.5% · San Francisco, CA

  Turbid pale color, abundant hoppy flavor and fruity aroma is deceivingly easy drinking.

  12oz 6 Pack Cans $10.99

• 3 Floyds Alpha King

  American Pale Ale · 6.66% · Munster, IN

  A bold yet balanced American Pale Ale with slight caramel sweetness and aggressive citrus hoppiness.

  12oz 6 Pack Cans $12.61

• 3 Floyds Gumballhead

  Wheat Ale · 5.6% · Munster, IN

  An American wheat ale brewed with white wheat and dry hopped with hand-selected hops from the Yakima Valley. Bright and refreshing with a lemony finish.

  12oz 6 Pack Cans $12.61

• 3 Floyds LazerSnake

  IPA · 7.5% · Munster, IN

  A good, old-fashioned Indiana Pale Ale brewed using malted barley grown in Indiana and Bavarian hops. Citrus, peach, and stone-fruit give way to even more tropical and grassy notes.

  12oz 6 Pack Cans $12.61

• 3 Floyds Zombie Dust

  American Pale Ale · 6.5% · Munster, IN

  This intensely hopped and gushing undead Pale Ale will be one’s only respite after the zombie apocalypse.

  12oz 6 Pack Cans $14.45

• Abomination Everyday Fog

  NE/Hazy DIPA · 7.1% · East Stroudsburg, PA

  DDH Double IPA w/ Mosaic, Pacific Jade, Citra, Summit & Enigma

  16oz Can $3.99

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $14.80

• Abomination Wandering Into the Fog (Galaxy)

  Double IPA · 8.6% · East Stroudsburg, PA

  Fluffy, pillowy, juicy, dank, DDH goodness.

  16oz Can $4.49

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $15.99

• Ace Joker Dry

  Cider · 6.9% · Sebastopol, CA

  A dry California cider made with 100% apple juice and full of champagne-like flavors.

  12oz 6 Pack Cans $10.99

• AleSmith Speedway Stout

  Imperial Stout · 12.0% · San Diego, CA

  A HUGE Imperial Stout that weighs in at an impressive 12% ABV! As if that's not enough, we added pounds of coffee for a little extra kick.

  16oz Can $4.49

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $16.99

• Allagash Swiftly

  IPA · 6.5% · Portland, ME

  16oz Can $3.85

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $13.99

• Artisanal Brew Works Brew Works Warheads Extreme Sour

  Sour Ale · 5.0% · Saratoga Springs, NY

  A wonderful collaboration between Artisanal Brew Works and Impact Confections, makers of Warheads candies. For this sour, we used our “She’s Tert” sour base but didn’t add any lactose to enhance the pucker power. GREEN APPLE - BLACK CHERRY - BLUE RASPBERRY - WATERMELON

  16oz Can $4.89

  16oz Can $17.99

• Artisanal Brew Works Peanut Butter & Jelly Multiple Infinities

  Stout · 9.0% · Saratoga Springs, NY

  Peanut butter flavored stout with cacao and raspberry puree

  16oz Can $6.49

  16oz 4 Pack Cans $23.99

• Athletic Downwinder NA Gose

  Non-Alcoholic · Stratford, CT

  Seasonal Gose - Notes of sea salt, coriander and lime leaf. Super quenching, sessionable summer style.

  12oz 6 Pack Cans $10.99

• View all Cans

Update this Beer Menu