The Pony Bar - Upper East Side

Recommendations Learn more

• Grimm Today’s Special

  American Pale Ale · 5.5% · Brooklyn, NY

  Inaugural pale ale for our new home at 990 Metropolitan Street in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, featuring Mosaic, Citra and Sorachi Ace hops.

  16oz Can $12

  Local|Great brewery

• Rockaway Black Gold

  Stout · 5.6% · Long Island City, NY

  Dark brown with a lasting coat of lighter brown head, and sheeting lace. Roasted coffee nose and flavor.

  14oz Draft $10

  Local

On Tap

• Bell's Oberon

  Wheat Ale · 5.8% · Comstock, MI

  Bell's Oberon is a wheat ale fermented with Bell's signature house ale yeast, mixing a spicy hop character with mildly fruity aromas.

  14oz Draft $10

• Brooklyn Summer Ale

  Blonde Ale · 5.0% · New York, NY

  English malt gives this light-bodied, golden beer a fresh bready flavor. German and American hops lend a crisp bitterness and a floral aroma.

  14oz Draft $10

• Captain Lawrence Citra Dreams

  NE/Hazy IPA · 7.0% · Elmsford, NY

  Our year round NEIPA packed with Citra hops, with notes of orange and pineapple. Perfect for any occasion!

  14oz Draft $10

• Central Waters Brewer's Reserve Call Me Old Fashioned

  Red Ale · 12.0% · Amherst, WI

  This is the Brandy Barrel Aged member of our series of "Old Fashioned" beers. An imperial Red Ale aged in Brandy Barrels with cherries. We then add orange bitters and Angostura bitters to the finishing tank prior to packaging for the true "Old Fashioned" experience.

  8oz Draft $10

• Finback Crispy Morning

  Pilsner · 5.2% · Queens, NY

  Pilsner dry hopped with Tettnanger, Blanc, and Citra hops

  14oz Draft $10

• Founders CBS 2019

  Imperial Stout · 11.3% · Grand Rapids, MI

  The highly sought after barrel-aged Canadian champ is back. Rich maple syrup, roasted coffee and velvety chocolate meld together to create the ultimate bourbon beer experience.

  5oz Draft $10

• Greenpoint Lekker Pilsener

  Pilsner · 4.9% · Brooklyn, NY

  14oz Draft $10

• Greenpoint Zwickel

  Kellerbier · 6.0% · Austin, TX

  Unfiltered Zwicklebier served in American Oak barrel.

  14oz Draft $10

• Grimm Maximum Intrigue

  Double IPA · 8.0% · Brooklyn, NY

  Mosaic and the hot ticket Sabro hops are giving us peak-ripeness notes of tangerine, mango, and stone fruit with a thick swirl of coconut cream

  11oz Draft $10

• Night Shift Nite Lite

  Pale Lager · 4.3% · Everett, MA

  An unfiltered, unpasteurized, all natural, craft light lager.

  14oz Draft $10

• Peekskill Simple Sour

  Sour Ale · 4.5% · Peekskill, NY

  This Sour is quick, dry and refreshing.

  14oz Draft $10

• Port City Optimal Wit

  Witbier · 5.0% · Alexandria, VA

  Brewed with raw wheat and oats, and steeped with coriander, orange peel and grains of paradise; complex and nuanced; yet crisp and refreshing.

  14oz Draft $10

• Rockaway Black Gold

  Stout · 5.6% · Long Island City, NY

  Dark brown with a lasting coat of lighter brown head, and sheeting lace. Roasted coffee nose and flavor.

  14oz Draft $10

• Smuttynose Finestkind IPA

  IPA · 6.9% · Hampton, NH

  A lip smacking copper-colored ale, with an aggressive hoppy, grapefruit flavor.

  14oz Draft $10

• Wild East Attitude Dancing

  IPA · 7.0% · Brooklyn, NY

  A classic San Diego-style IPA brewed and dry-hopped with Simcoe, Centennial & Columbus. Notes of dankness, citrus, fresh pine and dried grass. Bright aroma, forward-juicy and pleasantly bitter with a moderately dry finish.

  14oz Draft $10

• Wild East Moral Dilemma

  Imperial Stout · 8.5% · Brooklyn, NY

  A full-bodied imperial stout with decadent chocolate notes, spicy hops accents and dark cherry aroma. Rich maltiness is balanced with firm hop bitterness; bold flavors gradually mellow as the glass warms up.

  11oz Draft $10

Cans

• AleSmith IPA

  IPA · 7.25% · San Diego, CA

  Aromas of grapefruit and tangerine lead into an abundance of fresh pine and tropical fruit notes followed by a crisp, resinous bitterness.

  16oz Can $12

• AleSmith Speedway Stout

  Imperial Stout · 12.0% · San Diego, CA

  A HUGE Imperial Stout that weighs in at an impressive 12% ABV! As if that's not enough, we added pounds of coffee for a little extra kick.

  16oz Can $12

• Barrier Our Sour #11: Lupulin Lollies

  Sour IPA · 5.7% · Oceanside, NY

  This is our version of a sour tropical jolly rancher, it's just been disguised as a Sour IPA. Loaded with Grapefruit, Pink Guava and Soursop, which is a super cool tropical fruit that smells like pineapple and taste like strawberry-banana and citrus candy... more

  16oz Can $12

• Battery Steele Brewing Flume

  Double IPA · 8.0% · Portland, ME

  DIPA double dry hopped with Citra and Mosaic lupulin powder.

  16oz Can $12

• Blue Point French Toasted

  Brown Ale · 9.3% · Patchogue, NY

  Double Brown Ale with VT Maple Syrup, Cinnamon and Coffee Beans from East Coast Roasters.

  16oz Can $12

• Blue Point Lost Apparition

  Double IPA · 8.0% · Patchogue, NY

  DDH DIPA with Mosaic, Simcoe, Riwaka, and Nelson before finally hit with a charge of Mosaic and Simcoe Cryo hops.

  16oz Can $12

• Drowned Lands Wall Kill

  Sour IPA · 7.0% · Warwick ny

  Strawberry Rhubarb Sour IPA that’s fermented w/ several hundred pounds of strawberry purée, then conditioned with fresh sliced Rhubarb and dry hopped whole Madagascar vanilla beans, Taste of sugar cookies slathered in fresh strawberry preserves, pink lemonade drink mix, and late summer custardy ... more

  16oz Can $12

• Equilibrium Enso

  Double IPA · 8.2% · Middletown, NY

  We took aspects of our favorite past brews and integrated them to express a single manifestation of Equilibrium... more

  16oz Can $12

• Finback Above the Sea

  Double IPA · 9.0% · Queens, NY

  Double IPA double dry hopped with Galaxy, Mosaic Cryo, Citra, and Waimea hops

  16oz Can $12

• Finback Provisions

  IPA · 4.0% · Queens, NY

  IPA dry hopped with Amarillo, Cashmere, and Falconer's Flight hops

  16oz Can $12

• Greenpoint 2000 & Late

  Double IPA · 8.4% · Brooklyn, NY

  16oz Can $12

• Grimm Maximum Intrigue

  Double IPA · 8.0% · Brooklyn, NY

  Mosaic and the hot ticket Sabro hops are giving us peak-ripeness notes of tangerine, mango, and stone fruit with a thick swirl of coconut cream

  16oz Can $12

• Grimm Today’s Special

  American Pale Ale · 5.5% · Brooklyn, NY

  Inaugural pale ale for our new home at 990 Metropolitan Street in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, featuring Mosaic, Citra and Sorachi Ace hops.

  16oz Can $12

• Grimm Zonk

  Triple IPA · 10.0% · Brooklyn, NY

  Triple dry hopped with Mosaic, Simcoe, Citra, and an immense amount of Galaxy. This beer is loud with powerful aromas of cantaloupe, strawberry, and cannabis.

  16oz Can $12

• Hudson Valley Peach Silhouette

  Sour IPA · 5.0% · Beacon, NY

  Brunch-Style Sour IPA with peaches, and Mosaic & Citra hops

  16oz Can $12

• Tasty Looking Chops

  Pastry Stout · 10.5% · portchester

  chocolate covered pretzel pastry stout

  16oz Can $12

• Threes / Creature Comforts Guilt By Association

  NE/Hazy DIPA · 8.0% · Brooklyn, NY

  Double IPA with Passionfruit, Pineapple, Guava, and Tangerine. Beach Cooler, A Fistful of Skittles, Orange Crush, Joose, Ssipps Guava. Brewed in collaboration with Creature Comforts Brewing

  16oz Can $12

• Torch & Crown Tenement Pilsner

  Pilsner · 4.9% · New York, NY

  16oz Can $12

• Two Roads Hay Z Boy Hazy Juicy IPA

  NE/Hazy IPA · 7.0% · Stratford, CT

  16oz Can $12

• Wild East All Pretense

  NE/Hazy DIPA · 8.0% · Brooklyn, NY

  A soft, hazy, double dry-hopped DIPA brewed with flaked oats and pretentious amounts of Mosaic® and Cashmere hops. Notes of juicy papaya, nectarine, tangy citrus and melon.

  16oz Can $12

• View all Cans

Update this Beer Menu