Pies & Pints - Carmel

Recommendations Learn more

• Cigar City Maduro

  English Brown · 5.5% · Tampa, FL

  Pours brown in color with notes of caramel, toffee, chocolate, and hints of espresso.

  16oz Draft $6

  Rare|Popular|Great brewery

• Prairie Rainbow Sherbet

  Sour Ale · 5.2% · Krebs, OK

  Sour ale with rainbow sherbet flavors.

  12oz Can $6

  Rare|Great brewery

On Tap

• Ace Perry Cider

  Cider · 5.0% · Sebastopol, CA

  Ace Perry is an all-natural fruit cider. Fresh Pear juice and Madagascar Vanilla (for mouth-feel and smoothness) are added to our apple cider post fermentation.

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

• Bitburger Pilsner

  Pilsner · 4.8% · Bitburg/Eifel

  The classic Bitburger - a mature and most agreeable beer - is brewed with the best of ingredients in the same traditional way it has been for many, many years.

  16oz Draft $6.50

  60oz Pitcher $19.50

• Chilly Water Moonlight Sonata

  Vienna Lager · 5.1% · Indianapolis, IN

  Vienna Lager with an amber color and a balance of malt lending notes of carmel and warm roastiness to its light bodied drinkability.

  16oz Draft $6.50

  60oz Pitcher $19.50

• Cigar City Maduro

  English Brown · 5.5% · Tampa, FL

  Pours brown in color with notes of caramel, toffee, chocolate, and hints of espresso.

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Fat Head's + Pies & Pints Reagan's Comet (2021)

  NE/Hazy IPA · 6.9% · North Olmsted, OH

  This hazy was brewed in collaboration w/ Pies & Pints to support the Reagan Michael White Fund. We used Comet hops, paired w/ Azacca, Citra, & Mosaic to lend bright citrus zest & grapefruit aromas. Pineapple & orange flavors balance a light body & low bitterness to make this juicy hazy crush worthy.

  16oz Draft $7.50

  60oz Pitcher $22.50

• Fat Head's Grapefruit Goggle Fogger

  German Hefeweizen · 5.4% · North Olmsted, OH

  Our german style hefeweizen infused with fresh grapefruit.

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Fat Head's Head Hunter

  IPA · 7.5% · North Olmsted, OH

  This west coast styled IPA packs wicked hop flavors and aroma.

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Field Root Beer Dunkel

  Dunkel · 4.7% · Westfield, IN

  A clever spin on the traditional Munich Dunkel with the addition of Root Beer flavors makes this dunkel have a little bit of sweetness for a clean finish.

  16oz Draft $6.50

  60oz Pitcher $19.50

• Griffin Claw Blush

  Blonde Ale · 6.0% · Birmingham, MI

  Rose Blonde Ale brewed with Cranberry, Raspberry, Hibiscus, and Peach. Tartly light and freshly effervescent. Tickles of light bright berries tip the tongue with a clean earthly floral finish.

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

• Half Acre Burl

  Double IPA · 8.5% · Chicago, IL

  Burl is back. Burl captures a lot of what we strive for when making hazy Double IPA. Big in every way, HOP character with tactful reign, but nothing about the beer hangs too far out to make the other elements disappear... more

  12oz Draft $7

• Left Hand S'mores Milk Stout

  Milk Stout · 6.0% · Longmont, CO

  Our chocolatey marshmallow treat has caught fire! To create this s’more, we start with our classic Milk Stout recipe with just a slight tweak to the malt bull to accentuate graham cracker flavors. For the melted chocolate magic, we pour in Cholaca pure liquid cacao... more

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Lost Coast Tangerine Wheat

  Wheat Ale · 5.2% · Eureka, CA

  A refreshing citrus ale, Lost Coast Tangerine Wheat combines our Lost Coast Harvest Wheat with natural tangerine flavors.

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Maine Lunch

  IPA · 7.0% · Freeport, ME

  Our “East Coast” version of a West Coast-style IPA. Intense hop flavors and aromas of tropical and citrus fruits and pine dominate. A subtle malt sweetness brings the beer into balance.

  12oz Draft $7

• Maplewood Juice Jorts

  American Pale Ale · 6.0% · Logan Square, Chicago

  Its starting to get warm out so we cut the legs off of our Juice Pants! Rest assured, these Jorts are still weighed down heavily with hops. We used Citra & Azacca hops along with El Dorado hop hash and I swear, if we didn’t already cut the legs off our pants they’d blow off from the aroma!

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

• McClure's Bon Bon

  Cider · 5.9%

  An expression of our sweeter side, this cider is filled with fruity apple notes from the nose to finish. It is a lighter cider, but full of flavor with a refreshing naturally sweet finish. It is our take on the American Common Cider.

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

• Metazoa DDH Hoppopotamus: Citra

  IPA · 7.0% · Indianapolis, IN

  Our latest DDH Hoppopotamus features Citra hops. This give our classic IPA even more topical fruit flavor and aroma.

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Metazoa Nap In The Hammock

  Cream Ale · 4.7% · Indianapolis, IN

  Ah, the nap. The mark of the unhurried, those who revel in the most basic pleasures of life. A crisp, bright, fizzy brew - clean with a bit if malt character - is all the restful creature need desire... more

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Narragansett Lager

  Pale Lager · 5.0% · Providence, RI

  Brewed just right for drinking—crisp and refreshing. It’s got more flavor than other premium lagers, yet it’s one of the most drinkable beers in the world.

  16oz Draft $3

  60oz Pitcher $12

• New Holland Dragon's Milk Reserve: Salted Carmel

  Imperial Stout · 11.0% · Holland, MI

  The final Reserve of 2021 is an ode to one of our favorite releases. Our latest legend is aged for three months in select bourbon barrels and layered with sweet and salty caramel pretzel flavors. The result is a truly indulgent brew best described as dessert in a glass.

  12oz Draft $10

• People's Rhu the Barbarian

  Tripel · 8.0% · Lafayette, IN

  Belgian Tripel brewed with rhubarb. Pilsner malt, Abbey malt, and Belgian candi sugar give this ale a straw color. Noble hops, Belgian yeast, and an addition of rhubarb in the whirlpool make for subtle rhubarb flavors with spicy and alcoholic characters... more

  12oz Draft $7

• View all On Tap

Bottles & Cans

• Aecht Schlenkerla Rauchbier Märzen

  Smoked Beer · 4.8% · Bamberg, Germany

  Bamberg’s speciality, a dark, bottom fermented smokebeer.

  16.9oz Bottle $12

• Athletic All Out NA Stout

  Non-Alcoholic · Stratford, CT

  All Out Stout was built for cold weather. We recommend enjoying by the fire after a long day on the slopes. Expect a full-bodied mouthfeel and a pleasantly roasty finish, as well as delicate coffee and bittersweet chocolate notes. Don’t let anything slow

  12oz Can $5

• Athletic Upside Dawn NA Golden Ale

  Non-Alcoholic · Stratford, CT

  Refreshing, clean and balanced. This light-bodied golden ale is brewed with premium organic Vienna malt paired with a combination of English and American hops that add earthy, spicy and citrusy character.

  12oz Can $5

• Ayinger Celebrator

  Doppelbock · 6.7% · Aying, Germany

  It is full-bodied and velvety from half a year's aging. Although it is strong, it is not overpowering

  11.2oz Bottle $8

• Carlsberg Premium

  Pale Lager · 4.8% · Copenhagen V, Denmark

  A refreshing, bottom fermented lager beer with a clean, crisp taste and satisfying depth of flavour. It is full bodied and has a prominent, rich golden colour.

  16.9oz Can $5

• Chimay Premiere (Red)

  Dubbel · 7.0% · Baileux, Belgium

  First beer brewed by the monks of Chimay in 1862. Topped with a creamy head, it gives off a light, fruity apricot aroma produced by the fermentation. The taste perceived in the mouth is a balance confirming the fruity nuances noticed in the fragrance.

  11oz Bottle $12

• Coors Vizzy Hard Seltzer Pineapple Mango

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · Golden, CO

  Hard seltzer with antioxidant vitamin C from acerola superfruit.

  16oz Can $6

• Duvel

  Belgian Strong Ale · 8.5% · Breendonk-Puurs

  Duvel is a natural beer with a subtle bitterness, a refined flavour and a distinctive hop character.

  11.2oz Bottle $11

• Glutenberg Blonde

  Gluten Free Beer · 4.5% · Rue Dickson, Montréal

  Airy and lemony, its golden colour reveals floral and slightly herbaceous notes, giving way to a dry and tasty finish.

  16oz Can $7

• Glutenberg Red

  Gluten Free Beer · 5.0% · Rue Dickson, Montréal

  The use of roasted chestnuts endows this beer with toasted nuts and caramel hints, and gives it a unique aromatic personality.

  16oz Can $7

• Glutenberg Stout

  Gluten Free Beer · 5.0% · Rue Dickson, Montréal

  Robust notes of espresso coffee, dark chocolate and ripe dark malted fruit give it a pleasant mouthfeel that will not leave Stout lovers indifferent.

  16oz Can $7

• Kiuchi Hitachino Nest

  Witbier · 5.5% · Naka-Gun Ibaraki

  HITACHINO NEST BEER is a brand of our quality top-fermented ales. Since then, we’ve made a name and won numerous awards worldwide.

  11.2oz Bottle $9

• Lakefront New Grist

  Gluten Free Beer · 5.1% · Milwaukee, WI

  An all-sorghum beer. New Grist, a beer for Celiacs brewed from sorghum and gluten-free yeast grown on molasses.

  12oz Bottle $5

• Maplewood Fat Pug

  Milk Stout · 5.6% · Logan Square, Chicago

  With welcoming notes of dark chocolate and coffee, this Oatmeal Milk Stout combines a variety of roasted grains to produce a complex yet mellow flavor. Fat Pug is rounded out with sweetness provided by lactose and is named in honor of our brewer Adam’s pug, Otto... more

  16oz Can $7

• Metazoa Puppy Slumber Party

  Milk Stout · 6.9% · Indianapolis, IN

  Chocolate Milk Stout with Peanut Butter.

  16oz Can $7

• Metazoa Salmon Cannon

  IPA · 7.0% · Indianapolis, IN

  Crisp and dry with aromatic notes of citrus, pine and malt flavor

  16oz Can $7

• Odd Side Shadynasty's

  IPA · 7.0% · Grand Haven, MI

  A mouthful of resiny goodness and light malt with a semi dry body that hosts a well rounded bitterness. Pours hazy golden with a lacing white head.

  12oz Can $6

• Omission Pale Ale

  Gluten Free Beer · 5.8% · Portland, OR

  Bold, Hoppy, and Gluten-Free!

  12oz Bottle $6

• Orpheus Over and Over and Over

  Sour Ale · 8.5% · Atlanta, GA

  Packed with as much pineapple as we could, then rounded out with vanilla, this is a beer you’ll want over and over and over.

  16oz Can $8

• Orval Trappist

  Belgian Ale · 6.2% · Orval Abbey, Florenville, Belgium

  An intensely aromatic and dry character is highlighted by an additional dry-hopping in between fermentations.

  11.2oz Bottle $11

• View all Bottles & Cans

Cider

• Ciderboys Blackberry Wild

  Cider · 5.0% · Stevens Point, WI

  Apple blackberry hard cider.

  12oz Bottle $5

• Ciderboys Grape Stomp

  Cider · 5.0% · Stevens Point, WI

  Row after row of plump, purple grapes. Plucked fresh from the vine, jam-packed into a barrel, and ready for a good stomp. But wait...In comes crisp apple tartness to balance the natural sweetness of grapes. That's the aroma and rush of flavor captured in Ciderboys Grape Stomp. Get your feet wet.

  12oz Bottle $5

• Downeast Blueberry

  Fruit Cider · 5.0% · East Boston, MA

  Unfiltered Blueberry cider

  12oz Can $5

White Wine

• Alverdi Pinot Grigio

  Pinot Grigio · 12.0%

  A fresh, floral bouquet with notes of acacia flowers, this dry white wine is well-balanced with lively white fruit flowers.

  6oz By the glass $7

  750ml Bottle $21

• Broadbent Vinho Verde

  White Wine · 9.0%

  Slightly spritzy and featuring loads of crisp apple, peach, and apricot flavors and aromas.

  6oz By the glass $6

  750ml Bottle $18

• Clean Slate Riesling

  Riesling · 13.5% · Seattle, WA

  Ripe peach flavors balance ripe acidity, hints of lime and characteristic mineral notes and hints of spice.

  6oz By the glass $8

  750ml Bottle $24

• Douglas Hill Chardonnay

  12.5%

  This wine has flavors of pear, green apple, lemon zest and hints of honeysuckle, with a soft finish and a touch of buttery oak.

  6oz By the glass $6

• Isle St. Pierre Blanc

  White Wine · 12.5% · Arles, France

  Fresh, fleshy and floral, a great bistro-style sipping wine!

  6oz By the glass $6

  750ml Bottle $18

• J Lohr Chardonnay

  Chardonnay · 13.9% · San Jose, CA

  Full-bodied, balanced with flavors of pear, citrus and cream, with a lingering toasty oak finish.

  6oz By the glass $9

  750ml Bottle $27

• Kate Arnold Sauvignon Blanc

  Sauvignon Blanc · 13.5%

  Bountiful citrus aromas with tropical undertones. Focused and balanced with a clean finish.

  6oz By the glass $10

  750ml Bottle $30

• New Age Torrontes/Sauvignon

  Sauvignon Blanc · 9.0%

  A blend of Torrontes and Sauvignon Blanc, this is an effervescent, slightly sweet, vivacious white wine that is extremely refreshing. Ask your server about the 'Tincho' preparation over ice with a lime.

  6oz By the glass $7

  750ml Bottle $21

• Zonin Prosecco

  Prosecco · 11.0% · Gambellara, ITL

  Very well-balanced and appealing, with the extremely delicate almond note that is typical of Prosecco.

  8oz Bottle $8

Rosé Wine

• Domaine Bousquet Rose

  Rosé · Mendoza, Argentina

  6oz By the glass $9

  750ml Bottle $27

Red Wine

• Ancora Montepulciano

  Red Wine · 13.5% · Sanford, Florida

  Intense, robust with warmth, spice and aromas of damson and dried fruits. A palate of redcurrant and light smokiness with cherry on the finish.

  6oz By the glass $6

  750ml Bottle $18

• Beso Del Sol Sangria

  Red Wine · 8.5%

  100% Spanish Tempranillo grapes blended with lemon, orange, and a touch of cinnamon.

  6oz By the glass $6

• Bodini Malbec

  Malbec · 13.5% · Mendoza, Argentina

  An approachable Malbec that showecases the unique region of Mendoza Argentina.

  6oz By the glass $8

  750ml Bottle $24

• De Loach Pinot Noir

  Pinot Noir · 14.5% · Livermore, CA

  Opens with aromas of dark cherry & strawberry with a touch of delicate baking spice. Bright & lifted flavors of strawberry pie & a hint of brown sugar lead to a soft, round mouthfeel with medium body & a long, juicy finish.

  6oz By the glass $10

  750ml Bottle $30

• Douglass Hill Cabernet

  Red Wine · 12.5% · Ceres, CA

  Cherry, blackberry, & subtle spice flavors are just the surface of this wine. With each sip this wine reveals layers of oak, black pepper and hints of mocha.

  6oz By the glass $6

• Mayu Carmenere/Syrah

  Syrah · 14.5%

  Made in a style similar to old world Italian, this is a very fruit driven wine that is juicy (not jammy). Intense ripe blackberry and plum fruits with a touch of vanilla and spice.

  6oz By the glass $10

  750ml Bottle $30

• Stefano Farina La Ginestra

  Chianti · 13.0% · Erba, Italy

  Through a second fermentation – carried out by adding previously pressed grapes, achieves freshness, vivacity and very pleasant sensations on the palate.

  6oz By the glass $9

  750ml Bottle $27

• Sweet Red Reserve

  Red Wine · 11.0% · Bloomington

  Luscious, fruity, & just-sweet-enough, with familiar Concord flavor & a tough fizz.

  6oz By the glass $8

  750ml Bottle $24

• Woop Woop Cabernet

  Cabernet Sauvignon · 13.9%

  Smooth, rich & generously loaded with mulberries, black cherries & spice on the palate, the finish is long lasting, delicious, dense & fruit-packed.

  6oz By the glass $9

  750ml Bottle $27

• Yard Dog Red Blend

  Red Blend · 14.5% · South Australia

  Powerful cherry and plum aromas are brightened by minerals and dried flowers. Strong bitter cherry & dark berry flavors.

  6oz By the glass $9

  750ml Bottle $27

On Tap

• Bad Dad Tapestry Of Obscenity

  IPA · 6.6% · Fairmount, IN

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Big Lug Autumn Rye IPA

  Rye IPA · 6.8% · Indianapolis, IN

  Lovely crisp dry smooth rye with a bunch of hops. It is a mixture of autumn and hoppy summer all in one glass

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

• Fat Head's Bumble Berry

  Fruit Beer · 5.3% · North Olmsted, OH

  Brewed with fresh harvested spring honey, stolen from some very angry bees (we have the welts to prove it) and infused with our own special painstakingly, handpicked blueberry essence... more

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Fat Head's Wet-Hopped Head Hunter

  IPA · 7.5% · North Olmsted, OH

  A wet hopped version of the traditional Head Hunter

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

• Indiana City Yo! Mosaic

  NE/Hazy IPA · 5.5% · Indianapolis, IN

  This hazy pale ale is a whirlpool and double dry hop with Mosaic hops.

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Metazoa Gnat King Kolsch

  Kolsch · 5.0% · Indianapolis, IN

  his Kolsch-style ale is an exercise in balance and subtlety. Pilsner malt provides a clean malt character and a medium-light body that is complemented by Saaz hops. The long, cold fermentation and maturation of this ale creates a crisp and clean profile, and a harmony of flavors.

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Odd Side Crushie's Pineapple & Pink Guava

  Gose · 4.5% · Grand Haven, MI

  Gose style wheat ale with coriander, sea salt, pineapple and pink guava.

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

• People's Pilsner

  Pilsner · 4.5% · Lafayette, IN

  This beer is a twist on the Northern German style Pilsner, also known as Dortmunder or Export style Pilsner. These beers made use of hard water, like that of Lafayette, for that reason more malt was used and just enough hops to balance the beer... more

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Prairie Watermelon Girlfriend

  Sour Ale · 5.0% · Krebs, OK

  Sour ale with watermelon, sea salt, orange, lemon, lime, and natural flavor.

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

• Rhinegeist Kappa Flounder

  IPA · 7.5% · Cincinnati, OH

  This brew is bright orange and extremely hazy, offering intensely juicy notes of peach and mango complemented by a full, soft mouthfeel and low bitterness.

  12oz Draft $8

• Terre Haute Jungle Joose #2

  Berliner Weisse · 5.0% · Terre Haute, IN

  Smoothie-Style Fruited Berliner Weisse with Peach and Vanilla!

  12oz Draft $7

• Three Floyds Barbarian Haze

  NE/Hazy IPA · 6.5% · Munster, IN

  At long last, we bring you our take on a Hazy IPA. It’s no secret that most of our portfolio is hop forward, flavorful, and unfiltered. With Barbarian Haze, we took the hopping protocol a bit further, using some new age brewing alchemy coupled with our old school heavy handed approach... more

  16oz Draft $6

  60oz Pitcher $18

• Three Floyds Minostarr

  Saison · 7.0% · Munster, IN

  Hailing from the dark recesses of the galaxy, Minostarr was born in our stone fermentation tanks and combines two different yeast strains to produce bubblegum-like aromatics and a hoppy, earthy finish.

  16oz Draft $7

  60oz Pitcher $21

Update this Beer Menu