The Dark Horse Tavern

Recommendations Learn more

• Catskill Nightshine

  Schwarzbier · 5.5% · Livingston Manor, NY

  A full-flavored dark stranger for cold Catskill nights. Dehusked black malt ensures no bitter feelings.

  Draft $8

• KCBC Bodega Cat

  Oatmeal Stout · 5.9% · Brooklyn, NY

  A blend of premium English malts plus a healthy dose of flaked oats and a touch of crystal rye for layers of dark roast, bittersweet cocoa, black bread and a hint of tangy spice. Medium body, dry finish. Approachable and balanced.

  Draft $8

  Local|Great brewery

On Tap

• Barrier Money

  IPA · 7.3% · Oceanside, NY

  Light in color, light in body, heavy in hops! Bready pale malts do their best to support liberal hop additions.

  Draft $9

• Blue Point Dark Portal

  Porter · 6.5% · Patchogue, NY

  Step into the Dark Portal, where every sip transports you to a realm of rich, enigmatic flavors. Crafted with a masterful blend of Two Row, Pilsner, Munich, Chocolate, Black, and Crystal malts, this Robust Porter offers a silkysmooth brew that unlocks new depths of flavor.

  Draft $8

• Blue Point Imperial Sunshine

  Golden Ale · 9.6% · Patchogue, NY

  Our Imperial Sunshine is a bright, refreshing brew with a "bit of punch" - not for the faint hearted. Brewed with orange peel, this strong blonde ale packs a nose reminiscent of orange Tic Tacs, hard candy and our favorite non-alcoholic drink, Tang.

  Draft $11

• Busch Light

  Pale Lager · 4.1% · St. Louis, MO

  A light, balanced flavor, with fewer calories. A pleasant hop aroma and a smooth, slightly sweet finish.

  Draft $7

• Catskill Nightshine

  Schwarzbier · 5.5% · Livingston Manor, NY

  A full-flavored dark stranger for cold Catskill nights. Dehusked black malt ensures no bitter feelings.

  Draft $8

• Genesee Cream Ale

  Cream Ale · 4.9% · Rochester, NY

  We skillfully warm-ferment Genesee Cream Ale with our own signature top-fermenting yeast.

  Draft $7

• Great South Bay Roasty Toasty

  Stout · 6.0% · Bay Shore, NY

  Seasonal Stout with Chocolate Aromas, Roasted Barley& Flaked Barley Malts

  Draft $8

• Guinness Draught Nitro

  Dry Stout · 4.2% · Dublin, Ireland

  Rich and creamy. Distinctively black. Velvety in its finish.

  20oz Draft $9

• KCBC Bodega Cat

  Oatmeal Stout · 5.9% · Brooklyn, NY

  A blend of premium English malts plus a healthy dose of flaked oats and a touch of crystal rye for layers of dark roast, bittersweet cocoa, black bread and a hint of tangy spice. Medium body, dry finish. Approachable and balanced.

  Draft $8

• Kona Big Wave

  Golden Ale · 4.4% · Kailua Kona, HI

  It shines with its tropical hop aroma & flavor with a balance of sweet lightly roasted honey malt.

  Draft $8

• Magners Irish Cider

  Cider · 4.5% · County of Herefordshire, UK

  A unique Irish style cider made with 17 varieties of apples.

  Draft $9

• Mast Landing Champ Light

  Lager · 4.2% · Westbrook, ME

  A crisp, crushable, and refreshing American light lager.

  Draft $8

• Miller Lite

  Pale Lager · 4.2% · Milwaukee, WI

  The Miller Lite recipe uses a unique blend of choice Saaz and Pacific Northwest hops and a significant amount of caramel malt. Continues to be purposefully brewed for more taste, aroma and golden color than other light beers, with just 96 calories.

  16oz Draft $8

• Paulaner Hacker Pschorr Oktoberfest

  Oktoberfest · 5.8% · München

  Bavarian barley, slow roasted, caramelized to a rich, red amber color.

  Draft $8

• Shock Top Belgian White

  Wheat Ale · 5.2% · St. Louis, MO

  With real orange, lemon and lime peels and then added a little coriander spice to the mix.

  Draft $8

• Sierra Nevada Pale Ale

  American Pale Ale · 5.6% · CA & NC

  Unique piney and grapefruit aromas from the use of whole-cone American hops have fascinated beer drinkers for decades and made this beer a classic.

  Draft $8

• Stella Artois Pale Lager

  Pale Lager · 5.0% · Leuven, Belgium

  Premium European lager of noble traditions that is still brewed using natural ingredients in the same processes of mixing and fermentation used in the old days.

  Draft $8

Cans

• High Noon Pineapple

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · Memphis, TN

  High Noon Pineapple Hard Seltzer is made with real vodka and real fruit juice, sparkling water, and natural flavors. Only 100 calories, no added sugar, and gluten-free.

  12oz Can $10

• High Noon Watermelon

  Cocktail · 4.5% · Memphis, TN

  Made with vodka, real fruit juice, sparkling water and natural flavors. This crisp and refreshing drink only has 100 calories, no added sugar and it's gluten free. Enjoy straight from the can or served over ice.

  12oz Can $10

• Nutrl Watermelon

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · St. Louis, MO

  Watermelon Vodka Seltzer

  Can $9

• Nütrl Pineapple Vodka Seltzer

  Hard Seltzer · 4.5% · St. Louis, MO

  Hard seltzer made with real vodka, real pineapple juice and sparkling water.

  Can $9

• SpikedAde Electric Blue

  Hard Seltzer · 4.5% · Fairfield New Jersey

  Electric Blue is chill, refreshing, and always ready to keep the day flowing. For those that take the day/night as it comes with no judgement. With a crisp blast of that familiar flavor, it keeps the good times rolling and the night alive—no regrets.

  12oz Can $10

• SpikedAde Electric Red

  Hard Seltzer · 4.5% · Fairfield New Jersey

  Electric Red is the fierce, bold, competitor who is always on point. It packs a punch without burning out, perfect for those who crave big flavor without the extra and not afraid to be bold in life.

  12oz Can $10

• SpikedAde Electric Orange

  Other · 4.5% · Fairfield New Jersey

  Electric Orange doesn’t wait for fun—it creates it. Whether it’s a day full of action or a night that never ends, it’s made for those who seek adventure and are never afraid to stand out in a crowded room.

  Can $10

• Sun Cruiser Pink Lemonade + Vodka

  Hard Lemonade · 4.5% · Boston

  Hard Pink Lemonade with vodka.

  Can $10

• White Claw Lime, Black Cherry

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · Chicago, IL

  Lime, Black Cherry hard seltzers.

  Can $9

• White Claw Mango

  Hard Seltzer · 5.0% · Chicago, IL

  White Claw Mango is the perfect blend of seltzer water, the cleanest tasting alcohol base, and a hint of mango.

  12oz Can $10

Whisk(e)y

• Balcones Distilling Texas Single Malt

  Single Malt · 53.0% · Waco, TX

  NOSE ripe, buttered stone fruit, banana and pears; honey and rose water with delicate citrus accents TASTE silky and full on the palate; lightly toasted bread with fresh butter and marmalade FINISH long finish with lingering toast and burnt sugar notes morphing into rich malt and wood flavor... more

• Balvenie 12 Year Double Wood

  Single Malt · 43.0% · Dufftown, Keith, Scotland

  The Balvenie DoubleWood 12 Year Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky gains its distinctive character from being matured in two wood types, known as "wood finishing". Maturation in American oak casks mellows the spirit and imparts warming layers of vanilla spiciness... more

• Blade and Bow Bourbon

  Bourbon · 45.5% · Louisville, KY

  This bourbon has a subtle aroma of fresh fruit and a taste that includes hints of dried apricot, ripe pear, and a sweet roasted grain. The finish has notes of charred oak and warm winter spices

• Blanton's Single Barrel

  Bourbon · 46.5% · Kentucky

  A deep, satisfying nose of nutmeg and spices. Powerful dry vanilla notes in harmony with hints of honey amid strong caramel and corn. A medium finish composed of returning corn and nutmeg flavors.

• Breckenridge Bourbon

  Bourbon · 43.0% · Breckenridge, CO

  Made from yellow corn, green rye, and malted barley and aged two to three years. Although young, this Award Winning Whiskey combines a mixture of vanilla, caramel and oak flavors that fade into a fruity, spicy finish accomplishing an overall depth of flavor.

• Bulleit 95 Rye Whiskey

  Rye Whiskey · Shelbyville, Kentucky

  Bulleit Rye Whiskey, it takes the spice quotient almost to the max with a mashbill of 95 percent rye and 5 percent malted barley a 95 percent rye recipe.

• Bulleit Bourbon

  Bourbon · 45.0% · Shelbyville, Kentucky

  Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey. Characterized by a high rye content for a bourbon. Aged at least six years.

• George A. Dickel Tennessee 8 Year

  American Whiskey · Tullahoma, Tennessee

• Glenlivet 12 Year

  Single Malt · Glenlivet, Ballindalloch, Scotland

  Matured in a mixture of cask types, including American & European Oak. American oak imparts vanilla notes and gives the whisky its distinct smoothness. The mineral rich water from Josie's Well ensures the best possible results to form the flavors.

• Jameson Black Barrel

  Irish Whisky · Dublin, Ireland

  Time spent maturing in these barrels leads to intensified aromas of butterscotch, fudge and creamy toffee and flavors of spice, toasted wood, and vanilla.

• Jameson Orange

  Irish Whisky · 30.0% · Dublin, Ireland

  Jameson Orange delivers the smooth taste of triple-distilled Jameson Irish Whiskey, perfectly balanced with notes of zesty orange flavour.

• Jefferson's Ocean Aged At Sea Cask Strength

  56.0% · Crestwood, KY

  Jefferson’s Ocean, now bottled at 112 proof cask strength. We took fully matured Kentucky Bourbon, put it on a ship and sent it around the world. It crossed the equator 4 times, stopped at over 5 different continents and truly is a Bourbon of the World... more

• Jim Beam Hardens Creek Colonel James B. Beam

  Bourbon · 54.0% · Clermont, KY

  Using a longer fermentation process and taking it off the still at a lower distillation proof means Col. James B. Beam only needs to age 2 years to achieve a depth of flavor unmatched even by more mature bourbons. Proof that quality isn’t solely defined by time.

• Macallan 12 Year Sherry Oak

  Scotch · 43.0% · Easter Elchies Craigellachie, Scotland

  Matured at The Macallan distillery for a minimum of 12 years in Sherry oak casks from Spain, this is a classic, full-bodied Single Malt. Deliciously smooth palate of dried fruits, spice and wood smoke, leads to notes of flowers and sherry on the finish.

• Maker's Mark Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

  Bourbon · 45.0% · Loretto, KY

  Maker's Mark® Kentucky Straight Bourbon Handmade Whisky.

• Monkey Shoulder Blended Malt Scotch Whiskey

  40.0% · Scotland

  It's no secret that the three malt components that form Monkey Shoulder's smooth, malty and fruity character.

• The Singleton Singleton 15 Years

  Single Malt · Scotland

• Weller Special Reserve

  Bourbon · 45.0% · Kentucky

  The Original Wheated Bourbon Whiskey features an exceptionally smooth taste, substituting wheat for rye grain. Bottled at 90 proof, this bourbon stands out with its burnt orange color. Its softer flavor notes make this bourbon great for sipping or making cocktails.

• Wyoming Whiskey Small Batch Bourbon Whiskey

Update this Beer Menu